Keep it real

Keep it real

For more letters and to join the debate, visit www.NewScientist.com/letters mobabqbojfkbasfbtpqe^klk prmmloqfkdbsfabk`b+Vlroob^abop lrdeqql...

201KB Sizes 1 Downloads 73 Views

For more letters and to join the debate, visit www.NewScientist.com/letters

mobabqbojfkbasfbtpqe^klk prmmloqfkdbsfabk`b+Vlroob^abop lrdeqql_bfksfqbaql`lkpfaboqeb lqebopfablcqefpab_^qb^kaqeb bsfabk`bfkprmmloqlcfq+ Tbiifkdqlk)KbtWb^i^ka

plirqflkpqlmolqb`qfkd`efiaobk lkifkb)ibqrppqbmrm^ka_ofkd lro`efiaobk_^`htebobqebv _bilkdrkqfiqebvj^qrobbklrde qlj^k^dbpljbqefkdlro_o^fkp ^kajfkaptbobklqabsbilmba qlifsbtfqe+ Tfkkfmbd)J^kfql_^)@^k^a^

Keep it real ColjIfwE^qebobii)M^obkq Bar`^qlo)KbrcbiaFkpqfqrqb I^hpejfP^kae^k^obmloqp lkMbqfjl)^ol_lqf``ljmrqbo fkqboc^`bqe^q)fqfpelmba)tfii molqb`q`efiaobkcoljqeba^kdbop lcpqo^kdboplkqebfkqbokbq_v ^`qfkd^p^kfkqbojbaf^ovarofkd pl`f^ikbqtlohfkd%5J^v)m//&+ Vlrnrlqbqebabsf`bÑpfksbkqlo) >aof^kA^sfa@eblh)^pp^vfkd qe^qebt^kqpqlrpbMbqfjlÎql ebimabsbilmjlobk^qro^ierj^k clojplc`ljjrkf`^qflkÏ+Qebob fp^iob^ave^p^dllajlabiclo qefpÌob^imblmib)bpmb`f^iiv m^obkqp^kalqebo`^ofkd^ariqp+ Lrqpfabqebsfoqr^itloia)ob^i `ljjrkf`^qflkbslisbpk^qro^iiv+ Fcvlrt^kqqlhklttelvlro `efiafpq^ihfkdql)j^hb^mboplk^i fksfq^qflkqljbbqqe^q`efia^ka efploebom^obkqp+Qorpqvlro fkpqfk`qp7qebv`^k_b^ilqjlob ^``ro^qbqe^k^kvol_lq+ @ifkf`^impv`elildfpqDloalk Kbrcbiaprddbpqpqe^q_riivfkdfp ^kbumb`qbalrq`ljblcmrqqfkd `efiaobkqlljr`efk`lkq^`qtfqe

qebfombbop+Qefpmol_ibjfplkiv bu^`bo_^qba_v`efiaobkÑprpblc pl`f^ikbqtlohfkd)fk`irafkdqeb absf`bpabp`of_bafkvlro^oqf`ib+ Fkpqb^alcillhfkdqlqeb qb`eklildfpqpclobibd^kq

Clofkpq^k`b)fcqebbumbofjbkq t^palkbtfqeq^mt^qboqebkqeb afpplisba^fo`lkqbkqlcqeb eb^qbat^qbotfii_bc^oibpp+Qeb mobpbk`blc^kvjf`ol_r__ibplc ^fotfiifkqbocbobtfqeqebdoltqe lcqebf`bcolkq+Albpqebbccb`q pqfiil``rotfqeabd^ppba^ka abjfkbo^ifpbat^qbo< Kbt_rov)?bohpefob)RH

In cold water ColjBof`Hs^^ibk HbfqeOlppÑpbumi^k^qflkcloqeb Jmbj_^bccb`qalbpkÑqj^hb pbkpb%/1>mofi)m/2&+Eb^ppboqp qe^q^`lkq^fkbopqo^qfcfbatfqe olljqbjmbo^qrobt^qbo pbm^o^qfkdf`b^qqebqlm^ka1@ t^qbo^qqeb_lqqljtlriaklq e^sb`lksb`qflk+Qe^qfpklqqorb7 qebt^oji^vbofkqebjfaaib tlriaqlr`eqebf`b)`llilcc^ka pfkh+Fkc^`qqefp`lksb`qflktlria mol_^_ivmobsbkqqebcloj^qflk lcf`brkqfiqebbkqfob`lkqbkqp tbob^q^_lrq1@+ Eb^iplp^vpqe^qtebk prmbo`lliba^kaqebkmolsfaba tfqe^kr`ib^qflkbsbkq) mobsflrpiv`liat^qbotlria nrf`hivmolar`bjlobf`bqe^kqeb mobsflrpivelqt^qboÌtef`et^p `lkqo^ovqlte^qebe^al_pbosba fkm^oqf^iivcolwbkp^jmibp+Fcclo pljbob^plkqeb`liat^qbo prmbo`llip_rqqebelqalbpklq) qebkqebfkfqf^iivelqt^qbo`lria bkarmtfqe^iltboeb^q`lkqbkq qe^kqebfkfqf^iiv`liat^qbo+ Lk`bfqefqp-@fqobj^fkp^olrka -@)^kaqerpilpbpeb^qc^pqbo qe^kqebprmbo`llibat^qbotef`e fp`ilpboqlqebqbjmbo^qroblcqeb proolrkafkdcobbwbo+ Fqtlria_bfkqbobpqfkdql hkltte^qqebobpriqptlria_b fcqebcobbwbot^pjr`e`liabo qe^kkloj^i)p^v^q*.--@+ I^@lrokbrsb)Co^k`b ColjA^sfaPqbsbkplk >krj_bolcvlroob^abope^sb prddbpqbaob^plkpcloelqt^qbo ^mm^obkqivcobbwfkdc^pqboqe^k `liat^qbo+ Eltbsbo)fkprccf`fbkq fkcloj^qflklkqebbumbofjbkq^i `lkafqflkpe^p_bbkprmmifba+

Salt seller

t^qbo)drmmfbp`^k_bclrka ptfjjfkdqebobÌ^mebkljbklk jbkqflkba_v>kkbJ^droo^k ^kalqebopfkebopqravlk _be^sflro^iafsbopfqvfkdrmmfbp %>as^k`bpfkqebPqravlc?be^sflo) sli/1)m.22&+Qebcfpeafblcctebk qebt^qbobs^mlo^qbpfkqebaov pb^plk)_rqfqpbbjpqebfobddp `^kprosfsbqeb^ofa`lkafqflkp fkqebpb`obsf`bp)_b`^rpbqebv ob^mmb^otebkqebo^fkp`ljb+ Qbpqpe^sbobmloqbaivpeltk qe^qqebpbdrmmfbp^ob`^m^_iblc prosfsfkdlkivfkqebprimero*of`e t^qboplcqebMfq`eI^hb+ @olvalk)Proobv)RH

Rainbow worrier ColjQfjG^`hplk Ft^pafpj^vbaqlpbbqe^qKbt P`fbkqfpqe^parj_baaltkqlqeb buqbkqlckbbafkd^k^k^ildvclo qebdo^melc^nr^ao^qf`bnr^qflk fkPqbmebkLokbpÑp^oqf`iblk ColjGfjE^fde mi^vfkdmlli%5J^v)m01&+ Co^k`l@^mmr``fl^kaPfjlk Eb`lria^qib^pqe^sbmf`hba @^mbtbiij^hb^k^pprjmqflkfk pljbqefkdqebofdeqpe^mb+Ibpq qebfo^oqf`iblkqebeb^iqeofphplc tbclodbq)^o^fk_ltfp^k^o`lc b^qfkdp^iq7qe^qte^qmblmibt^kq ^`fo`ib`bkqobalkqebpe^alt jlobqe^k^kvqefkdbipbfpqlifsb lcqebsfbtboÑpeb^a)^kae^p clo^ilkdqfjb%.J^v)m//&+ qebp^jb`ros^qrob^iiqebt^v Pljbmblmib`lkpfabofqjlob ^olrka+Qebdo^melc^nr^ao^qf` fjmloq^kqqlbkglvifcbqe^kqlifsb crk`qflkfp^m^o^_li^)qeb ^pilkd^pmlppf_ib)^kabkglvfkd `ros^qroblctef`eobar`bp lkbÑpcllafp^kfjmloq^kqm^oqlc moldobppfsbiv^ilkdfqpibdp+ qe^q+Fc^pmofkhifkdlcp^iqj^hbp E^pifkdabk)I^k`^pefob)RH jvcllaq^pqb_bqqbo)Fpe^iiq^hb qebp^iqÌ^kaqeb`lkpbnrbk`bp+ Pfk`btb^iie^sbqlafbpljbqfjb For the record lcpljbqefkd)Falklqqefkhqe^q N The experiments into the Mpemba jvp^iqfkq^hbtfiimrq^kvbuqo^ effect, detailed in Keith Ross’s letter, _roabklkqebjbaf`^ic^`fifqfbp+ Mbqbo_lolrde)@^j_ofadbpefob)RH were carried out by student teachers in training, not by primary school students (24 April, p 25).

Tough eggs Colj>kav?b_fkdqlk Vlro^oqf`iblkjf`ol_bpprosfsfkd fkqebMfq`eI^hbfkQofkfa^a %/1>mofi)m.2&objfkabajblc _bfkdqliatefiblk^sfpfqqebob qe^q`lksb`qflk`roobkqpfkqeb ^pme^iq`ob^qb^ob^ppfjfi^oql pr_ar`qflkwlkbp+Fkqebtbq pb^plk)tebkqebpb^ob^pcfiitfqe

Letters should be sent to: Letters to the Editor, New Scientist, 84 Theobald’s Road, London WC1X 8NS Fax: +44 (0) 20 7611 1280 Email: [email protected] Include your full postal address and telephone number, and a reference (issue, page number, title) to articles. We reserve the right to edit letters. Reed Business Information reserves the right to use any submissions sent to the letters column of New Scientist magazine, in any other format.

5 June 2010 | NewScientist | 25